(September 08, 2006) There is no talent
shortage, the "war for talent" is being fought over nothing. The incessant
whining about a lack of "qualified talent" is an obnoxious code for ageism,
racism and other forms of bigotry.
That's one way of looking at the data we've been
reviewing this week. (see
War 1,
War 2 and
War 3)
The domestic workforce in the United States is
nearly 150 Million strong. Another 100 million go to work in ways that are not
counted in the workforce (lawyers, doctors, contract workers, small business
people). 35% of the people who work each day change their work each year. (It's
not the same 35% each year.)
That's a lot of people in play.
In addition, the domestic population will grow
to nearly 400 Million by 2050, a surge of 33% in 40 years. That's a lot of
people, most of whom (94%) will be immigrants who arrive here old enough to join
the workforce. (Remember the immigrant age distribution chart?)
So, what's all the fuss about a labor shortage?
We think it has a number of roots:
While a population expansion of 33% seems
pretty big, the economy needs to grow by 130% over the same time just to
stay out of recession. The anti-shortage thinkers insist that this hurdle
can be overcome by productivity improvements. New overtime regulations
expanding the group who should work OT without compensation may help in this
regard. If everyone worked 100 hour work weeks, there would definitely be no
labor shortage.
Skill mixes are changing. For example,
construction supervisors must now be bi-lingual. HR Managers (and other
beneficiaries of outsourcing) must have contract compliance experience and
skills. In a number of categories, ready-made employees just aren't
available. There may be more than enough people, just not too many with the
right skills.
Given the changes in workforce composition
(age, gender, ethnicity) that have taken place already, many in leadership
(who are looking to replace the white guy who just left) have trouble
understanding how to manage through cultural and language barriers.
The media and techniques used to reach
prospective employees have undergone a revolution. The hiring manager and
recruiter have a vast number of tools available to do the job. There is
little quantifiable data about which works and which doesn't.
The personnel requisition process generally
fails to account for any market factors before it is executed. By neglecting
market level compensation and general local availability of resources, the
requisition process causes huge amounts of waste in hiring. This waste is
often seen as evidence for a labor shortage.
The labor force is not spread evenly around
the country (or the planet for that matter). There are, in fact, shortages
in one discipline or another in local economies. A national view of the
question is not very useful.
The idea that the labor market should
rapidly provide the exact set of people with the exact set of skills,
temperaments, aptitudes, attitudes and work ethics is an arrogant and self
serving approach. It neglects to account for the value and importance of
innovation and entrepreneurship in the development of an organization.
It smacks of classism and the desire for entitlement.
So, the answer is that there is and isn't a
labor shortage. To the extent that you desire a ready trained and available
workforce at your whim, there's a problem. To the extent that you are willing to
articulate your needs clearly and invest in the people you hire, there's not
much of one.
If we are really going to continue to grow the
economy at 20th century rates, we'll have to make some changes. Economies with
pyramid age distribution structures are better suited for that.
On Monday, we'll look at the planning tools
required to navigate future labor requirements.
Talent is what matters most.
Hire the best with Authoria Recruiting.
Authoria Recruiting 2007 is a next-generation recruiting solution that helps you:
Understand exactly what talent your managers need.
Find the best sources.
Target and attract the highest quality candidates.
Hire top talent and track their success.
The most widely-used enterprise recruiting solution on the market, Authoria Recruiting helps our customers manage private talent pools totaling over 11 million candidates.