interbiznet: The Recruiting News

The Recruiting News













Please Click On Our Sponsors


Please Click On Our Sponsors


Recruiting News for the Human Resource Professional


Please Click On Our Sponsors


Please Click On Our Sponsors



Please Click On Our Sponsors


Please Click On Our Sponsors




 

 

 

Click On Our Sponsors



Click On Our Sponsors





 

 

 






Click On Our Sponsors  


The Electronic Recruiting News is a Free Daily Newsletter For Recruiters, HR Managers, Advertising Agencies and Clasified Advertising Operations



|
ERN | Bugler | The Blogs | Archives |Careers | Job Hunt |
Visit our Jobs In HR Section.


Annual Job Review Is 'Total Baloney,' Expert Says

(July 19, 2010)
Employee performance reviews should be eliminated, according to UCLA business professor Samuel Culbert. "First, they're dishonest and fraudulent. And second, they're just plain bad management," he says

The problem with the practice, Culbert tells NPR's Renee Montagne, is that periodic reviews create circumstances that help neither the employee nor the company to improve. As Culbert and his co-author, Larry Rout, write in their book, Get Rid of the Performance Review! annual reviews do not promote candid discussions about problems in the workplace and their potential solutions.

Instead, Culbert says, when workers undergo a review, "They're going to talk about all their successes it becomes total baloney."

And management participates in the charade, as well, he says: "The boss already has heard [from] his boss what they want to pay the guy, or the woman. So they come up with a review that's all backwards."

The process can frustrate employees, who may have a lot at stake from a raise or promotion to the general arc of their career. And at the least, they want their contributions and talents to be recognized. Rather than using performance reviews, Culbert suggests that management "just tell the employee what he or she needs to do to become more effective."

Culbert's book sprang from an article he wrote for The Wall Street Journal in 2008, which sparked a large response from readers.

Asked if performance reviews might be tweaked instead of eliminated outright for instance, a manager might use statistics to measure an employee's effectiveness Culbert says that one-dimensional measurements can bring a new set of problems.

"Once you set up the metrics, that's the only focus for the employee," Culbert says. "The problem with performance reviews is that the metric that counts most for the employee is the boss's opinion. So the employee starts doing what he or she thinks is going to score in the boss's mind, and not even talk about what he or she believes is necessary for the company to get the results that really matter."

For anyone who would like to gauge where they stand on the annual review issue, Culbert and Rout have posted a test on their site, with the slightly biased title of How Much Do You Hate Performance Reviews?

Read more at NPR Colleen Gildea
colleen@interbiznet.com

Permalink  . -.  Todays Bugler  . -.  Send To a Friend  . -.  Readership Feedback

Digg         Delicious         Reddit                 StumbleUpon





Guide to the
Top Specialty Boards
Where Top Candidates Seek Career Opportunities
Call Center CallCenterJobs.com
Drivers / Trucking JobsInTrucks.com
Enviro/Occup. Health & Safety EHSCareers.com
Executive RiteSite.com
General JustJobs.com
Health / Medical HealthJobsUSA.com
Logistics JobsInLogistics.com
Manufacturing JobsInManufacturing.com
Retail AllRetailJobs.com
Security Clearance USADefenseIndustryJobs.com
For more Specialty Boards, visit:
The
Employer's Corner on TopUSAJobs.com
marketing@TopUSAJobs.com

For more great articles - search our archives:
HR Jobs:
Jobs In Human Resources Management Section.



Enjoy the Bugler and review the latest Recruiting Blogs.




Contacting Us:
interbiznet
Mill Valley, CA 94941
415.377.2255
colleen@interbiznet.com

Copyright © 2013 interbiznet. All rights reserved.
Materials written by John Sumser © TwoColorHat. All Rights Reserved.



The Electronic Recruiting News
Sign-up to receive this newsletter in email each day.
Email Address:
Request: Subscribe Unsubscribe
 
The interbiznet Bugler
Sign up and receive a concise, daily briefing on recruiting industry news.
Email Address:
Request: Subscribe Unsubscribe
 


Click On Our Sponsors



ERN | Bugler | Blogs | Candidates | Advertise | HR Jobs |

 

 

 
 
FEATURES:
 

FREE
EMAIL NEWSLETTERS:

  -  BUGLER
    (Sign-up)
    Industry News

  -  ERNIE
    (Sign-up)
    Industry Article


      

 



RECENT ARTICLES:
  • Annual Job Review
  • Business Environment
  • Improving Market
  • .jobs
  • Newspaper Primer
  • Behavioral Targeting
  • Craigslist's Traffic
  • Fund Your TEAM
  • Staffing adds Employ
  • Video Sales JB
  • Hiring Report
  • Health Care Reform
  • Performance Eval
  • Background Screen
  • Global RPO Report
  • Employ Engagement
  • SHRM Conference
  • WEDDLE Awards
  • US IT Workforce
  • Attract, Retain, Repel
  • Team Building
  • Hiring Uptick
  • Employment 101
  • Entry Level Job Outlook
  • Customers on Your Team
  • Employment Law Update
  • 5 Myths and Facts
  • interbiznet Survey
  • Retained Search Market
  • Finacial Retirement Needs
  • Hiring Rebound
  • IHRIM Conference
  • 10 Ways to Improve Hiring
  • Starting to Hire Again
  • Recruiter's Outlook
  • Role-Based Assessment
  • HR Psychographic Survey
  • Disability Survey
  • Dice Report
  • Online Ads
  • Job Market Optimism
  • Hodes iQ Report
  • Hiring recovery
  • Tolerate It
  • Labour Shortage
  • Economic Recovery
  • Global Workforce
  • Recruitment Prediction
  • Monster Working Tour
  • E-Branding Social Web
  • Social Media Marketing
  • Recruitment Genome

    ERN ARCHIVES



         © 2013 interbiznet.
         All Rights Reserved.