
Middleware
(May 20, 2003) --
Here's a surprise. Many customers own electronic recruiting systems that do not
do what they want them to do. Whether it was the IT department demanding
consolidation on a single platform or the over-promise of a sales person, lots
of e-recruiting tools are basically broken.
The market has started to grow in the cracks.
Since the first of the year, we've talked with 20 vendors who offer products
designed to:
- Filter Job Board Flows
- Measure Job Board Results
- Overlay existing tool sets (ERP and ATS)
- Realign Commercial Processes for Third Party
Staffing Usage
- Finish the integration work left undone by
vendors
- Shield IT from embarrassment
After all these years of a down market, the
entrepreneurial energy is focusing on fixing the broken stuff. It's an
interesting development with lots of opportunity:
- With hundreds of installations, only 5% of
their customers will even turn on the Peoplesoft system. It's unusable.
- Recruitsoft still struggles mightily with
online integration.
- BrassRing continues to have major
implementation trouble.
- Webhire customers continue to hope.
- Resumix shows promise but will take years to
mature.
- Job Boards continue to provide unfiltered
fire hoses of data volume.
Although clear long term solutions are available,
budgets remain tight. Triage can be acquired when the bleeding is intense. It's
harder to organize a full acquisition. Many recruiters are relying on paper
processes with the stacks piled on top of the computing tools that were supposed
to ease their burdens. So, the middleware is selling. Much of it is crap.
There are, however, a couple of interesting
bright spots. They tend to be built by seasoned veterans with humble
aspirations. You won't find a single plan for world dominance or a hint of the
holy grail. They simply produce systems that produce results in the surprisingly
fractured world in which we live.
Employment
Engineering, a Santa Clara firm, offers a number of modular solutions for
enterprise and ATS customers who wish their systems performed as advertised. Led
by Jeff Hunter and Tom Bahlo, two long term industry veterans, the company is
focused on results delivery. With a number of large clients under its belt, the
company makes its living by making the unworkable work.
Behavior
Description Technologies focuses on getting very essential interviewing
techniques embedded into the flow of data from job boards. The key here has
always been minimizing the time investment required from candidates and
recruiters alike. Tom Janz, the Industrial Psychology community's wiliest
entrepreneur is on to something simple and useful here. Check out their essessor.
A quick look at McFrank
Advertising would lead you to believe that they'd fail quickly on the web
(they're our current candidate for worst ever agency web design). But, the
company provides a job-by-job process that integrates advertising and selection.
We think of it as a job ad turbocharger. The results are powerful.
As far as the others go, there are a number of
folks who purchased failed software from dot com ventures who are trying to
repackage it. A number of the usual suspects are making the same old claims. In
all, it's the usual quality mix...20% of the stuff is where the value is. Take a
look at the three we mentioned today.
- John Sumser, © TwoColorHat. All Rights Reserved.