
Pretty Good
(May 5, 2003) --
The commercials are running regularly
on CNN. It's a powerful and compelling pitch. Walmart, it turns out, is far
ahead of most in the move to Employment Branding. It's clear that Walmart is
trying to jump into the lead in the race for resources that will accompany the
coming uptick.
Whoever put the television ad campaign together
ought to be congratulated.
They also ought to be asked to contact the people
who run Walmart's career site.
Far better than most, the career section of
Walmart's website has easy access to investor
information, charity programs,
employee
profiles and benefits
information. There's a jobs database, a way to submit resumes and the best
spin possible on life
in Northwest Arkansas.
Although Walmart employs over 1,000,000
"associates", the vast majority of those jobs can not be filled using
the internet. (Even TGI Fridays
moves waiters and waitresses over the internet.) Instead, one goes to the
internet to discover that the best way to apply at Walmart is
Visit your local store's Personnel Manager for
applications and more detailed information about this and other jobs.
In a way, that's okay. The rest of the
functioning detail of the employment site is a contradictory and badly planned
execution. If candidates actually used the internet to apply for a job, they'd
encounter a maze of contradictions. For example:
- The "Hourly
Employment" page may be the single longest and most confusing array
of job descriptions on the net. "District
Managers" and "Personnel Managers" will be pleased to
know that this is where their job descriptions are housed.
- While it's reasonably clear that no one will
ever be hired as a district manager by a local store manager. the normal
"apply at your local store" text is a part of the job description.
- Many of the jobs listed in the hourly section
can only be found by reading through the 17,000 words on that page.
- Although you can apply
online, it means downloading an Acrobat file to fill out.
- Although there is a "submit
resume" function, it is not tied in any observable way to the
various job openings.
- Many of the jobs
database entries tell you to email your resume to a headhunter.
- All of the database listings contain confusing
and misleading internal status information.
Even in Northwest Arkansas, internet penetration
is deep enough that the employment section of the Walmart page is the first
encounter candidates have with Walmart as an employer. It's a very bad first
impression.
While the corporate message is "We put our
people first."
That is, of course, unless they use the internet
to apply for a job.
Employment branding is far more about the
experience of looking for work at a company than it is about good television
ads. We'd suggest that Walmart pull the ads until their website is up to snuff.
- John Sumser, © TwoColorHat. All Rights Reserved.