The Recruiting News
New interbiznet Bookclub
interbiznet
Find out more
Got a news tip?
Articles |
Home | ERN | Bugler | The Blogs | Blogroll | Advertise | Archives | Careers
Name Change Game (September 1, 2000) Here's our favorite new economy Christmas Carol.
All I want for Christmas is a new company name. To say that logos and branding are substituting for real progress is to understate the severity of our rapidly evolving devotion to the inane. Icarian, kforce, spherion, vibratron, alexus, aquent, angami, and a cast of others have chosen to lead the industry with names and logos that obfuscate. (Obfuscate is a confusing sounding word that means confuse and muddy.) With seventeen variations on the Nike swoosh (hmm, a bent line indicates our deep commitment to flexibility), the march towards a single generic inane brand is tireless. Fortunately, a new company has emerged to help the less affluent in our audience come up with their own 21st Century brand name and swoosh logo. eNormicon is the outgrowth of a growing backlash against the trend. Here are some more links that show the depths of the backlash:
- John Sumser © TwoColorHat. All Rights Reserved.
Do layoffs mean that our ongoing assertions about labor shortages are out of kilter?
With over 7,000,000 businesses in the United States (and 30,000,000 around the world), it's not very surprising that some of them screw it up some of the time. Given human fallibility, it's surprising that more of them don't make mistakes more of the time. The labor shortage, we bet, is a predictor of more layoffs, not less.
CDI (whose stock is discovering new lows) covers some of the issues in a new paper called "Me-commerce". Although we think that the company's willingness to substitute cleverness for substance is a large part of their stock problem (me-commerce, c'mon), there's an element of truth underlying their discoveries: Competition for workers shortens the distance between two jobs. As average tenure declines, management styles have to change. When they don't, companies fail.
In a time of shortages, layoffs just may become more commonplace, not less.
- John Sumser © TwoColorHat. All Rights Reserved.
It's with no small amount of surprise that, on our return to the Knowledge Universe website, we were extremely taken by both the company's vision and its progress towards it:
Knowledge Universe is the face of the first really innovative competitor in our space. With an awe inspiring commitment to profitability and social change, the company is in the process of acquiring all of the bits and pieces required to deliver life cycle labor supplies. Not a database of aging names, but profitable engaging businesses that reach out and deliver real value to working people. A glance at the portfolio of Knowledge Universe Companies gives you a sense of the potential breadth and depth of a competitor in our arena. Knowledge Universe offers precision reach to "passive" candidates over the entire course of their career life-cycle (literally from cradle through retirement).
According to their website,
- John Sumser © TwoColorHat. All Rights Reserved. At its root, the traditional job fair creates an "us and them"
marketplace with little visible room for the middle ground. On the whole,
the assumption underlying traditional job fairs is that the carney
mentality ("marks" strolling by booths) works for all participants.
Although sophisticated job fair producers will assure you that the real
business of a job fair is competitive intelligence (and therefore a third
category of player), it's a well kept secret. Most carnival goers are
oblivious to the deeper possibilities on the midway.
For the most part, job fairs sell hope to candidates and recruiters.
Recruiters pay with money and candidates pay with time. Everyone invests
hope. In that way, job fairs are very similar to most job boards and free
agent markets.
To counter this underlying dynamic, Talent Labs is selling
skills, interactions and possibilities to candidates and recruiters. Like
many experiments, the underlying thesis is intuitive. Like many event
development prospects, the process will be evolutionary. In its first
iteration this fall, the event will be a pragmatic attempt to find out
what works and what doesn't.
You've got to envy Fast
Company's position. Rather than having to push towards an IPO under
the stringent scrutiny of investors, the operation is harvesting an
audience they've built for adjacent reasons. That gives them an
extraordinary edge in the process.
Although we can rant for hours with cynicism about the Fast Company audience, the truth is
that they all identify themselves as free agents or change agents. One of
the magazine's constant themes is the development of "Me, Inc.". Focused
on proactive and hard charging professionals and managers, the magazine
provides hope and encouragement as a component of an annual subscription.
This leaves them positioned to cover other things in the Talent Labs. It creates an
environment for Silicon Valley Recruiters that is significantly higher
quality than Craigslist (or its
Boston equivalent). They appear to be able to execute the experiment
profitably while learning how to improve the process over time.
It's interesting, we think, to have a non-participant in our industry
point out the fact that the local Recruiting market can be very nicely
segmented along quality lines. From the way that most analysts cover the
space, you'd have to think that one job board would dominate a region or
industry segment. Really, we think that profitable candidate pools can be
built in numbers that look more like 10,000. Talent Labs is trying to
show that it can be done in lots of 2,000.
- John
Sumser Normally, we like to see businesses that want to make customers happy.
We get a comfortable feeling from offices located in working
neighborhoods. We're reassured by an executive who wants to make his
customers successful.
That's not to say that experimentation or "out of the box" thinking
isn't important. In today's employment environment, it takes a combination
of pure devotion to customers and a willingness to take calibrated risks
on their behalf. The question is, at the root, who owns the risk.
Some things need a desperate fix and customers are excited about the
prospect.
If you haven't seen Fast
Company magazine, it's probably because you haven't been in an
airport, at a newsstand or in the reception area of most players in our
industry. Founded by an ex Harvard Business
Review managing editor, Fast Company is a highly influential business
magazine targeted at new generation leaders and professionals. The goal of
the operation is:
Built on the hard work of Paul Burrowes and the early team at Westech
(now BrassRing), job fairs have
traditionally been high-energy networking, intelligence gathering and job
interview events designed to keep the candidates who attend them in the
know. With a cattle-call feeling, the center of the game was always the
vendor booths. On a heavy day, it was like walking down the old Las Vegas
strip with hawkers at each booth trying to persuade passers-by to come
visit.
The Fast Company Alternative, Talent Labs, is designed to
get all of the players into the center of the event. Conceptually, the
recruiters' booths are at the fringes of the event while the "main court"
is designed to create an environment in which a new form of peer-to-peer
recruiting can emerge. The idea behind "Talent Labs" goes something
like this:
In a labor scarcity in which free-agent style mechanisms are becoming
the dominant way that leaders and professionals acquire the next
assignment, recruiting is a peer-to-peer transaction.
For that reason, the events appear
to make the interesting assumption that recruiters are also looking for
their next gig. The goal of Talent Labs seems to be to
create a momentary marketplace in which skills can be polished,
connections can be made and deals can be initiated. That's why the
attendee list includes CEOs, recruiters, vendors from our industry, Fast
Company readers and job hunters. By experimenting with the traditional
definitions of the job market (you know, it's no more than buyers, sellers
and vendors), Talent Labs
is all about finding the next level of effectiveness for Fast Company's
range of customers.
We think it's a lot more than a simple experiment and plan to be there.
If you can squeeze it into your schedule, you ought to.
We plan to fill you in further as the event approaches.
NOTICE: |
1st
Steps In The Job Hunt FEATURES:
RESOURCES:
ADVERTISING: RESOURCES:
Stocks We Watch
AOL
Pending IPOs
- None
Public Staffing Cos
ACSYS |